User blog comment:Captain hobo/Wiki player guessing game/@comment-2084412-20120206023523/@comment-2084412-20120206164203

Step is correct, let me give you why -

The boatswain should give 5 lashes, not 6.

The lookout said he was looking for a red sky because it was a warning, but it was night, and per the saying "A red sky at night, is a sailor's delight. Red sky in the morning, is a sailor's warning."

So, at night, it isn't a warning, it's a delight, so the lookout and the boatswain drank up the rum!