User blog comment:Tamabot/Checking in/@comment-3242795-20130424200906/@comment-3432656-20130425003935

If he is a bad admin then it is not the past tense of he was a bad admin. It would make more sense to say he is a bad admin to emphasise that he being or ever holding said position of admin will always be in John's view, a bad admin. If he becomes admin right now. "He was a bad admin" in John's opinon would be false since in your minds he was a admin or was a bad admin. Thus...

John: 3

Benjy: -1