User blog comment:Captaingoldvane2/Riddle/@comment-3112181-20120420211303/@comment-3112181-20120420212217

67 gold coins + 1 "mastered" skull + 1 QAR symbol in minimap + 2 mutineer sea charm symbols + 2 loot rating skulls + 1 crew leader skull + 5 people's heads + 1 PvP rank skull + 1 sword mastered skull + 3 gold coins in "treasure scense boot" icon + 1 head in "open fire" icon = 85

(if you count the "o_O" and "-_-" emoticons said in chat as "faces", then it'll be 87. Also, for the 67 coins, if you count the gold coin icon itself as "1 skull", and then 67 others for the number making 68 in all, then it will be 88).