User blog:Tama63/Demote to Admin - Jzfredskins(Passed)

{| class="parchment" align="center" style="width:100%; margin-top:1em; margin-bottom:1em; color:black; border:1px solid #C4A010; background-color:#E0C555; ; ; " cellspacing="0" cellpadding="20" http://images2.wikia.nocookie.net/__cb20110918002149/logocreation/images/e/e2/Pirates_otC_Online_Players_Wiki-wordmark.png
 * style="font-family:Blackadder ITC; text-align:center; font-size:30pt" |
 * style="font-family:Cordia New; font-size:18pt; " |
 * style="font-family:Cordia New; font-size:18pt; " |

This is a review to see if the User "Jzfredskins" really needs sysop powers.

Activeness
He claims he cant edit that often due to "schooling", but he is active on the "Pirates Online Wiki" he usually makes 1 edit a day here( see edits section for details).I dont think he has the "welfare" of the wiki at heart any more.He may be seeking adminship on the "Pirates Online Wiki" which he is already a rollback of.

Edits
Now his edits are either to aid the "Pirates Online Wiki" or sabotage links to a forum where the members have their own section(discussion happened between the users and forum staff).Or he is either complaining about something that happened.He is too inactive to know whats going on.

see http://potcoplayers.wikia.com/index.php?title=Template:Mainpageaffliates&diff=prev&oldid=301900

His Previous Review
Well he deleted it

Admin Powers
Since he is so inactive but active on another wiki, I suggest he does not need any admin powers, or he should not be a bureaucrat.He has not been performing the role of moving Userboxes from the test page to the official page, same with the page banners.

His Respect for this Wiki
Lately he has had no respect for this wiki. I believe he is trying to get admin rights on the "Pirates Online Wiki"

My Views
Jz has changed a lot recently he is no longer the fun guy from the start of the Summer, he I feel has become too serious and inactive.

Action
I will most likley pass this on to a board of users to provide feedback to me, before I discuss anything with the admins.

I suggest
 * 1) Either a demotion to sysop, losing bur powers
 * 2) To rollback
 * 3)  John Breasly ,   Former Admin 
 * 4)  . Benjamin   Macmorgan
 * 5) To user
 * 1) To user
 * 1) No Action

Board of Users/Rollbacks to View this

 * 1) Benjaim McMorgan
 * 2) John Breasly
 * 3) Captain Shadow
 * 4) GenLawrence
 * 5) Jack Pistol

Refs
Signed, Tama
 * 1) http://potcoplayers.wikia.com/index.php?title=Special:Log&user=Jzfredskins
 * 2) http://potcoplayers.wikia.com/wiki/Special:Contributions/Jzfredskins
 * style="font-family:Blackadder ITC; text-align:right; font-size:30pt" |
 * style="font-family:Blackadder ITC; text-align:right; font-size:30pt" |
 * style="font-family:Blackadder ITC; text-align:right; font-size:20pt" |
 * style="font-family:Blackadder ITC; text-align:right; font-size:20pt" |
 * }

Discussion before this blog
In my opinion, he should be demoted to rollback. When he DOES edit, he edits well, but that is so rarely. Also, he often goes against other admins decisions(i.e. Jim Logan's conest), and plays by his own rules (Smart Snaps advert crisis).- John Breasly ,   Former Admin 


 * I agree that Fred hasn't been very active on this wiki, while is active on others. In that point, it means he is done with this wiki, so he shouldn't be admin anymore. He would be a good roll-back and such, but admin... he's lacking activness Gen Lawrence Guild 


 * Either to rollback or admin, I am kinda unsure. A good person overall but too inactive... I don't know... I am leaning to rollback.




 * I agree with him being demoted to rollback. It seems that hes too interested in "abusing" his admin powers, then actually helping the wiki.


 *  . Benjamin   Macmorgan



The Voting
The vote will end when 1 side gets 20 votes or after 1 week ,the highest side will "win".This is a vote for a demotion of Jzfredskins to Rollback due to the reasons above.Jz may not block during this time