User blog:Voxelplox/Rule Request: Community Votes on unbanning users

I find it sort of funny how certain "users" who have offended the rules and hurt others emotionally are unbanned without community say. To put a more Democratic Option to voting and how this wiki works, I'd like to suggest that a new rule put place.

Read the following to see the full parts of the proposed rule,

I have 2 ideas for the rule, BOTH are different

Rule idea 1: Pros: More power to the admins over this

Cons: Less amount of Community Choice

1) If a user requests being unbanned it must go through a admin.

2) A admin vote takes place, if the majority of admins agree the unban request goes to the next phase

3) A community wide vote takes place.

4) First side to get to 20 wins, Only users who have not been banned in the last 1 month may vote.

Rule Idea 2

Pros: Community Choice

Cons: Less admin choice over subject

1) If a user requests a unban he will be unbanned just to defend himself ( he/she will have exactly 2 ( admins may adjust the defense time ) days to defend himself or herself and then banned again )

2) After the banned user gives his/her defense a community vote takes place.

3) Registered users only may vote, must have not had a ban in the last 1 month

4) First side to 20 wins

5) If the blocked user was not banned forever, the community can fight to lengthen the subjected person to a longer ban which would be either approved or declined by the admins then voted by the community.

Estimated time of the first rule: 2-4 days for voting and approval ( might be shorter )

Estimated time for the second rule: 4-8 days for voting, defense, and length of ban ( might be longer or shorter )

Purpose of proposed rules: They will help organize unban requests, as it seems admins just unban users without the consent of the community ( which sort of helped them become admins )

So I'd like to request a community vote on this rule. Im sick of waiting, and its time we organize things up a bit. There are flaws with everything, but somethings can be fixed easily. Which is why im proposing this to you all today.

Signed,

 Benjamin Macmorgan  TalkUser BlogSpecial:Contributions